New heels often feel stiff, tight, and unpredictable. Breaking them in properly is about shaping the shoe to your foot while protecting your skin and avoiding permanent damage to the materials. If you rush the process or use extreme hacks, you may end up with cracked straps, stretched-out uppers, or heels that never feel stable. A smarter plan gets you comfortable faster and keeps your shoes looking new.
Begin by confirming the fit is close enough to break in. There’s a difference between “needs softening” and “wrong size.” If your toes are crushed, your heel won’t stay in place, or the arch feels completely misaligned, breaking in won’t fix it. The best candidates for break-in are shoes that feel slightly snug or stiff but not painful, with your foot positioned correctly in the shoe.
Do a short at-home wear schedule first. Put the heels on for 15–20 minutes on day one, then increase by 10–15 minutes each session over several days. Walk on a clean, hard surface so you can feel the real pressure points, but avoid rough outdoor pavement until the shoes feel stable. The goal is to let the materials warm and flex while you identify exactly where rubbing occurs.
Target stiffness safely. If the shoe is made of leather or a flexible material, gentle stretching is effective. Wear thick socks and walk around for short intervals, focusing on the areas that feel tight. If you use a shoe stretcher, use it gradually—small adjustments over time are better than forcing a dramatic stretch in one night. For specific pinch points, a cobbler can spot-stretch a problem area without distorting the entire shoe.
Heat can help, but only with restraint. Mild warmth from your body while wearing the shoes is usually enough. Intense methods like blasting the shoe with a hair dryer can weaken glue, warp synthetic materials, or cause patent finishes to bubble. If you do use gentle warmth, keep it brief and keep the heat moving, never concentrated on one spot.
Protect your skin before friction starts. Blisters form from repeated rubbing, so prevention matters more than treatment. Apply an anti-chafe balm where you typically rub, such as the back of the heel, the sides of the toes, and the edge of the strap. Consider silicone heel grips if your heel lifts slightly. If the shoe rubs at the ankle or a strap edge, a small piece of moleskin can create a buffer while the shoe softens.
Mild warmth from your body while wearing the shoes is usually enough.
For more in-depth guides and related topics, be sure to check out our homepage where we cover a wide range of subjects.
Add the right cushioning, but avoid overcrowding. Ball-of-foot cushions can reduce pressure and help prevent the “burning” sensation under the forefoot. However, thick inserts can push your foot upward and forward, making the toe box tighter. Choose slim, well-placed pads and test them at home. If your toes suddenly feel cramped, switch to a thinner option.
Work on grip and stability while breaking in. New soles can be slick, especially on smooth floors. Lightly scuff the outsole on a safe surface or ask a cobbler to add a thin traction sole. Better grip reduces the instinct to tense your toes, which is a major cause of cramps and forefoot soreness.
Practice the movements you’ll actually do. Many heels feel fine in a straight line at home but fail on stairs, turns, or long standing periods. During break-in sessions, add gentle turns, stop-and-go walking, and a few steps up and down (carefully). This helps you discover whether the shoe supports your foot during real-life motion.
Know when to pause. If you feel numbness, sharp pain, or a hot spot that intensifies quickly, take the shoes off and address the issue. Continuing through pain can create blisters, bruised toenails, or strained arches. If a pressure point persists after a few sessions, it may be a design issue—like a poorly placed seam or an unforgiving toe box—that won’t improve enough.
Finish with a “dress rehearsal” before you wear the heels for a big day. Put them on for 60–90 minutes while doing light household tasks. Use the exact inserts, heel grips, or balm you plan to wear out. This final test catches small problems early, when you still have time to adjust.
Breaking in heels doesn’t need drama. With a gradual schedule, smart stretching, and proactive blister prevention, you can get that comfortable, molded-in feel without ruining the shoe. That’s the Fit in Heels approach: protect your feet, protect your investment, and enjoy the style without the suffering.